Home › Resources

Security and Compliance · November 5, 2026

Cyber Insurance Requirements: What Carriers Expect at Your 2027 Renewal

Cyber insurance applications have changed. A few years ago, renewing meant a short form and a signature. Today the application asks specific questions about how you protect logins, computers, and backups, and some carriers check parts of your answers by scanning the systems you expose to the internet. If your policy renews on January 1, you are about two months out. That is enough time to close most gaps if you start now.

Why the application got longer

Carriers pay for what goes wrong, and the losses are large. The FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center received more than one million complaints in 2025, with $20.9 billion in reported losses. Business email compromise alone accounted for more than $3 billion of that.

Insurers see the same pattern in their own claims. One cyber insurer's 2026 claims report found that business email compromise and funds transfer fraud made up 58 percent of the incidents it handled in 2025, and that ransomware was its most expensive type of claim, at an average loss of $269,000.

So underwriters now ask how you would stop the attacks they pay for most. Marsh, one of the largest insurance brokers, says the adoption of certain controls has become a minimum requirement of insurers.

The controls that come up again and again

Every carrier writes its own application, and requirements vary by industry, size, and the coverage you buy. Still, the same few controls appear on carrier applications and in broker guidance again and again.

Beyond those, expect questions about security awareness training, how quickly you install updates, and whether you still run software the manufacturer no longer supports. If you still have Windows 10 computers, our guide to what changed for Windows 10 after October 13 covers your options.

Read your own form, not a generic checklist

Forms differ in what they ask, and in what they leave out. One widely used application, in its September 2024 edition, asks about multi-factor authentication in four separate places and lists eight backup protections to choose from. It does not ask whether you have ever tested a restore, and it does not ask about an incident response plan by name. Broker guidance treats both as key controls.

That gap works in two directions. A question you were not asked this year may appear next year. And the questions you were asked will be read closely after a claim. The safer approach is to build to the full list, then answer your own carrier's questions exactly as they are written.

How the application lines up with the CIS Controls

Our security work is guided by the CIS Controls, a set of security practices published by the Center for Internet Security. It is a useful lens for reading an insurance application, because the framework sorts its safeguards into groups. Implementation Group 1 is the starting set, which the Center describes as essential cyber hygiene for every organization. Implementation Group 2 adds safeguards for organizations with more to protect.

Read the application against that structure and a pattern shows up. Some of what carriers ask about sits in the starting set. Some of it sits in the second group.

What the application asks aboutCIS Controls v8.1 safeguardGroup
MFA for remote access6.4 Require MFA for Remote Network AccessStarting set (IG1)
MFA for administrators6.5 Require MFA for Administrative AccessStarting set (IG1)
Backups kept apart from your network11.4 Establish and Maintain an Isolated Instance of Recovery DataStarting set (IG1)
A tested restore11.5 Test Data RecoverySecond group (IG2)
Endpoint detection and response10.7 Use Behavior-Based Anti-Malware SoftwareSecond group (IG2)
A written incident response plan17.4 Establish and Maintain an Incident Response ProcessSecond group (IG2)

The practical lesson is simple. A business that has done only the starting set can still have to answer no on its application. If a provider tells you that you meet a security framework, ask which group, and then check the items in the second group against your form.

Answer every question truthfully

This is the part that matters most. Answer every question accurately, even when the honest answer is no.

In 2022, a carrier asked a federal court in Illinois to rescind a company's cyber policy after a ransomware attack. The application had said multi-factor authentication protected the company's systems. According to the carrier's complaint, it protected only the firewall. The company agreed to the rescission, and the court entered judgment for the carrier in August 2022. Rescission means the policy is treated as though it never existed.

A no on the application is a gap you can close.

A false yes can cost you the whole policy.

If you cannot check a box today, close the gap first, then apply. If it cannot be closed before the deadline, answer accurately and tell your broker what you are doing about it.

A renewal timeline, working back from your date

If your renewal is closer than 90 days, start at whichever step matches your calendar. The order still holds.

Where Iron Gate fits

The controls carriers ask about are part of the core service we deliver: managed endpoint security with detection and response on every device, identity and access protection in Microsoft 365, and backup and recovery plans we design, manage, monitor, and test. Iron Gate carries cyber liability insurance as well.

When a client's renewal comes up, we typically help them fill out the application, so that each answer matches what is actually in place.

None of that replaces your own answers. Your business signs the application, and every answer on it should be one you can stand behind.

Frequently asked questions

What happens if we answer no to a question?

It depends on the carrier and the question. It can mean a higher premium, an exclusion, a request to fix the gap before the policy is issued, or no change at all. Each of those is better than a false yes.

Is traditional antivirus enough?

Check the wording on your form. Many applications ask for endpoint detection and response, or a managed detection service, and ask you to name the product. If the form asks for EDR and you run traditional antivirus, the accurate answer is no.

Do the requirements depend on our industry?

Yes. Carriers price and underwrite by industry, size, revenue, and the coverage limits you choose. The controls in this article come up across most applications, but your own form is the one that counts.

Even if we never work together, you should walk into your renewal knowing that every answer on the application is true.

Talk it through before you renew

If your renewal is coming, we will review your renewal application with you before it is submitted and give you a candid read on where you stand. The first conversation is with the owner, about your business and whether we are a good fit for each other.

Schedule a Conversation

Prefer the phone? Please feel free to call us at (412) 265-6311. We are happy to help.

About the author

Carl Kunzmann is the founder and CEO of Iron Gate Technology. He has been building Pittsburgh IT companies since 2003 and founded Iron Gate in 2012; many client relationships go back further than the Iron Gate name. He works with Western Pennsylvania businesses on practical technology decisions: reliability, security, and long-term value.

← All articles